Saturday, November 27, 2010

Washington in our pantries



With Thanksgiving leftover still filling our fridges, it’s hard to think of something that brings people together more than food. This is true even in the political arena, where a controversial food safety bill is making strange bedfellows of such disparate groups as free-spirited organic farmers and other localvores and buttoned-down free-market think tanks types.

At the center of debate is senate bill 510, the FDA Food Safety Modernization Act, which is slated for a full senate vote as early as Monday of this week. While advocates say this act will streamline efforts by the FDA and other agencies to keep the United States’ food supply safe, opponents wonder why a food supply already described as “remarkably safe” by the Center for Disease Control needs federal agencies tinkering around with it. They also worry about the negative effects it will have on food prices in general and small farm, organic and artisan products in particular. These, of course, are the very food producers which power a large segment of Vermont’s local and state agricultural economy.

S. 510 re-emerged this fall after a salmonella outbreak this past summer resulted in the recall of half a billion eggs and at least a thousand ill. Fortunately the incidence of salmonella poisoning and most food-borne illnesses has steadily declined over the past few years; but we will never be able to eliminate all risk in life. This summer’s outbreak occurred despite the fact that the Food and Drug Administration already has broad powers of regulation over food safety and production. Funny how government agencies often reward themselves with more power when they screw up, while private companies lose customers and market share and are subjected to congressional hearings when they make mistakes.

Unfortunately, Vermont’s farmers and specialty food makers may feel the brunt of this latest power grab. Though an amendment has been added to this legislation to help relieve small food producers from the over-burdensome nature of the new regulation, it establishes arbitrary limits that make little difference in real terms. For instance, the Tester amendment allows small producers - those earning $500,000 or less in annual sales - to continue under state and local regulations. As soon as they exceed that amount the full force and cost of the legislation comes to bear. With the current economic policies being enacted by the federal reserve and widespread fear of inflation, especially in commodities, that $500,000 number may be reached quickly in the next few years.

Another feature of the Tester amendment - an exemption for those selling most of their food directly to consumers, local restaurants and retailers within a 275-mile radius - makes little sense in practice. Consider this: a cheesemaker from Middlebury could sell her wares to retail outlets in Rochester, New York, which is about 229 miles distant, but has to register with a new federal regulatory agency, submit to federal inspections, fill out a copious amount of paperwork and then keep track of regulation as it changes and becomes more demanding (as it always does) to sell the same cheese to stores in Buffalo, which is 293 miles away. Within large states like California and Texas federal regulations would apply to intrastate commerce.

Large food producers have sophisticated operations able to deal with government requirements. Small producers rarely have the extra financial or or personnel resources to keep up with the onerous burdens increased government regulation necessitates. A few years the Consumer Product Safety Improvement Act was passed and the prohibitive costs associated with adhering to this legislation drove hundreds of small toy manufacturers out of business. Meanwhile, companies such as Mattel and Hasbro live on to stock the shelves for yet another Christmas buying season..

There is one important check on businesses both large and small - the free market. Consumers should be able to decide which risks they are willing to take and which they are willing to pay extra to avoid. In the case of eggs, for instance, pasteurized eggs are widely available in grocery stores, though at a higher price. For those who like to eat cookie dough or make Hollandaise sauce, the extra cost might be worth it. For the rest of us, maybe not so much. Are we not capable of assessing the level of risk without Washington imposing on us safety levels above and beyond what we decide we need?

Businesses have nothing to gain by sickening their customers. It is in the best interest of all companies, large and small, to produce high quality products and quickly remove those that do harm. The pressure of competition encourages businesses to provide the best products possible. Our nation’s food supply is the safest in the world not because of government agencies but because producers are held accountable to consumers.

Monday, November 15, 2010

Corporatism vs. Free Market Capitalism, (and a call to action)

The idea of central planning as the underpinning of an economic system, whether labeled “Socialist”, “Communist”, or “Fascist” is repugnant to those who support free markets, or what might be broadly referred to as “Capitalism”.

There is however an equally repugnant but more insidious system that has materialized without many open advocates or a genuine philosophical underpinning. For lack of a precise term, it might be known as “corporatism” or “crony capitalism”, mixed in with a few tablespoons of genuine fascism. Basically, this is the economic and political system that reigns supreme in the contemporary United States of America. This system is abhorrent to free market principles and its economic effects are disastrous to the vast majority of citizens. In addition, it makes a mockery of the rule of law and destroys individual liberty, initiative, and the entrepreneurial spirit. Perhaps even more diabolical however is the fact that this system persists while masquerading as genuine “capitalism” and a system of “free markets”.

Our entire education system (up to and including elite post-secondary and graduate schools) along with the big-named economists, pundits and mainstream media talking heads persistently emphasize the idea that the United States is a society based on capitalism and the concept of free markets. During our 200+ year history, there have been periods where the description was generally accurate. In the current economic environment, the bones of the free market have been picked clean by the corporatist vultures and only the pale ghost of capitalism remains. Yet, the so-called mainstream thinkers are remarkably successful in maintaining the illusion and allowing the widespread damage and economic injustices of rampant statism and central planning to be blamed on free market capitalism.

Under this guise, the so-called “financial crisis” of 2007 and 2008 led many to suggest that we were witnessing the great failure of free markets and the culmination of the Marxist prophecies predicting capitalism’s demise. Beyond the smoke and mirrors however, we were seeing the bright beacon of the free market’s potential and the bloody fingerprints of central planning on a grievously wounded economy. An edifice based on decades of interest rate manipulation (repugnant to the principles of a free market) combined with statist interference in the mortgage industry (a-la Fannie, Freddie, FHA, etc.) and a culture of widespread federally sanctioned fraud stood poised to come crashing down with a delicate wave of the invisible hand. Even after this prolonged period of rule bending and statist intervention, the force of the free market was being felt. The perpetrators of fraud and those whose greed had led them to massive mal-investment were about to be punished. The culprits at the Federal Reserve and the central planners in government were on the verge of having their meddling and mis-allocation of resources explode in their faces. Only a massive and unprecedented onslaught of government support and an insane money-printing spree were able to sustain the system. Temporarily.

Fraud is generally repugnant to any society or economic system, and especially so to the advocates of a free market. Though they cause temporary distortions, frauds and swindles are ultimately expunged by the fundamental nature of the free market. Thanks to massive statist intervention and active government participation in the perpetration, legitimization and obfuscation of fraud, this warped system of U.S.-style corporatism has been remarkably persistent. Monumental interventionism has granted the system a temporary stay of execution, and the spectre of the free market has been momentarily banished. Yet another layer has been added to the economic house of cards. Financial institutions remain bankrupt by any fair or accurate accounting standards. The Federal Reserve is single-minded in its focus to suck every last drop of blood from the productive economy to keep the parasites alive. Commodity prices increase in the presence of stagnant wages causing pain to the lowest income earners. Value-adding producers in the real economy see their operating margins compressed to oblivion as their input costs rise with zero ability to pass on price increases to the wealth-stripped customer. Massive government deficit spending (now accounting for nearly 10% of GDP), is necessary just to keep up the slightest fiction of economic recovery, and an incessant string of spurious (later revised) government statistics is seized upon by the mainstream media propaganda machine as evidence of progress.

Economic prognostication in this environment of statism and interventionism is a fool’s errand, but it is likewise foolish to suggest that any of the major economic trends are moving in a direction likely to yield improvement for the average U.S. citizen. The free market WILL ultimately prevail. Whether it triumphs by a sudden “return to sanity” in the current environment, gradually works through a period of prolonged economic misery, or arises from the ashes of a general societal meltdown is the only question. Regardless of how the end game plays out however, those who would champion liberty, sound monetary policy and free markets have a MISSION! It is our imperative to expose the doppleganger of corporatism and shatter the illusion that the economic malaise of the 21st century United States of America is due to shortcomings of the free market or capitalism. Whether we fix the problem now, or in years hence are left only to fix the blame, the economic misery of millions must be inextricably linked to the corrupt corporatist system and the miserable failure of central planning.

Thursday, November 4, 2010

Thoughts on Green Mountain Communes

Green Mountain Communes: The Making of a Peoples’ Vermont

http://www.anarkismo.net/newswire.php?story_id=7248


I found this article giving a brief history of Vermont communes to be a fascinating read which should be enlightening for people across the political spectrum. The examples are a microcosmic genesis of contemporary political tension. I was entirely enthused with the concepts up until the descriptions of militarism and the subsequent “Progressive Party” type ideas.

The spirits of local entrepreneurship, cooperation, sustainability, gender equality and voluntary social arrangements are all excellent. If the current crop of "Progressives" would take a little bit of individual (or collective) initiative and attempt to solve social problems by similarly creative and ambitious means, perhaps it could serve as a "model" for others to follow.

Perhaps the contemporary progressive movement has instead fallen prey to a certain intellectual laziness or collective myopia? Rather than working in a system of voluntary participation such as these early communes, the current "Progressive" ideal has been twisted into a belief system which advocates that resources be extracted from INvoluntary participants through the use of force. These resources are then reallocated by nonproductive central planners in an attempt to achieve an outcome which might represent an “idealized” version of these bygone communes. Such an outcome was never genuinely achieved by these systems, as indicated by the eventual dissolution of the groups, and such an outcome is definitely unachievable through coerced participation.

I fully support the local farmer's markets and food co-ops and buy from local producers as much as possible. I'll donate to local charities and lend a hand to my friends and neighbors in times of need. I make these choices willingly. If a group of my fellow Vermonters desire, by mutual agreement, to set up a communal living arrangement and behave in accordance with their own social norms, values and microeconomic systems, I would steadfastly defend their freedom to do so.

However, when such a group of people organize (i.e. politically) and decide that it is within their right to confiscate wealth from others by the use of force, and then attempt to re-shape all of society to conform to THEIR subjective ideals, I will resist. Mr. Houriet believes that future economic conditions will motivate people to adopt a more communal societal arrangement such as the early communes described. If that eventuality is indeed in our future, so be it. We will then choose freely to participate. As of now, economic necessity does not mandate this style of living and it is therefore immoral and unjust to use government as a mechanism to compel such arrangements on unwilling participants.

Wednesday, November 3, 2010

Have a cup of tea


The American people have just erected the largest and most important trade barrier in history - they said no to the importation of European democratic socialism and decided it’s time to support to the greatest product this nation has ever produced domestically - constitutional government based on the principles of economic and political freedom.

Oh, sure, there are still a few European wannabes holding out for their piece of France - our own beloved Vermont and much of New England, New York and California come to mind. But this election has shown the rest of the country is responding to messages of fiscal responsibility, limited government, free markets and individual liberty and responsibility. Not at all coincidentally, these are the very ideas that have been found on placards, heard in speeches and expounded upon in numerous opinions pieces since the Tea Party movement roared into existence eighteen months ago.

The people of the Tea Party have overcome tremendous opposition in their fight to restore accountability to American politics and policy. First they were dismissed, then mocked, then attacked. According to a famous quote from Mahatma Ghandi, that is the natural progression in any situation when a bunch of upstarts dares to take on authority.

But then, Ghandi said, you win.

The Tea Party has entered the “win” phase. In a relatively short time, it has evolved from scattered groups of citizens holding rallies marked by the singing of patriotic songs, recitations of the pledge of allegiance, opening and closing prayers, dissertations on American history and more than a few angry speeches and into a collection of politically savvy activists. For some months now the Tea Party has been defining the terms of our national debate.

This reality strikes fear in the hearts of established politicians, who rather enjoy spending their days figuring out ways to increase their own wealth, power and status. Having to work with people supported by country-class rubes is rather distasteful. Republicans already know this, having already been forced to rub shoulders with these candidates. Democrats are about to meet the riffraff.

Tea Party-backed candidates who are heading to Congress have a quaint but specific mandate from voters - they are expected to actually read and understand the Constitution of the United States and honor the spirit of the document that codifies the uniquely American political philosophy based on the concept of natural law and its byproducts - maximum individual liberty, state sovereignty and limited national government.

None of this fits the ruling class agenda so its contempt for those of us who still share the founders’ vision knows no bounds. But what really frustrates the Washington elite, politicians and pundits alike, is that the Tea Party is such a moving target. It provides no leader to besmirch and attack because it is composed of millions of motivated citizens working together in thousands of small groups for a common cause. The charge that the Tea Parties receive millions of dollars in funding from shady outside sources is patently untrue. As someone who heads a small group here in Bennington, is associated the larger Vermont liberty movement and counts many New York Tea Party members as friends, I know that every time we want to rent a fair booth or order a box of pocket-sized Constitutions we have to pass the hat.

I also know the liberty movement’s motto, “Don’t Tread on Me,” applies to politicians and fellow travelers alike. Media pundits who only understand centralized power cannot accept this new paradigm and keep trying to make the members of the liberty movement fit into their Washington box of consensus building and compromise. But trying to control this movement is like herding cats. Each town, county and state organization is different from each other and from their counterparts across the country. We’ve agreed to disagree on many issues and remain civil and cooperative as we stand committed to those political values on which we can unite. The Tea Party may be the embodiment of the form of government our founders envisioned for this country, one truly organized by and for the people.

The American people understand bigger isn’t necessarily better when it comes to most things, especially government. They understand the solutions to our difficulties can be found within the American people and the communities they comprise. They are willing to do what needs to be done but they are no longer willing to beg for Washington’s permission to govern themselves and their communities as they see fit. Increasingly they realize that what D.C. does or doesn’t do should be irrelevant in American lives.

Their challenge, now that they have reached this new understanding, is to make sure their representatives also understand and respect the new American paradigm and, when it comes to government, keep buying American

Saturday, September 11, 2010

A September 12th Do-over


Sometimes I fantasize about what I wish George W. Bush had said and done following the 9/11 attacks. My alternative version goes something like this:

My Fellow Americans;

My heart goes out to the victims of yesterday’s horrific attack at the World Trade Center in New York City and the Pentagon in Washington D.C. It swells with deep admiration and gratitude for the courage and determination of the passengers of Flight 93, whose heroism defies description. It also mourns the death of the innocence of the American people, whose security and confidence have been so severely shaken.

I have spent the night in solemn prayer on behalf of the victims and their families, whose shock and anger I share and whose grief I can only begin to comprehend. Please know that the American people stand - and kneel –in complete sympathy and solidarity with you. This attack on Americans on American soil will not go unanswered and we promise your loved ones have not died in vain.

Over the past twenty-four hours I have consulted my foreign policy team as well as my own understanding of this event and my feelings about it. I have spent much time in deep reflection about what this tragedy means to the United States today and her many tomorrows. I humbly acknowledge that how we respond to this attack will have serious consequences for our nation and the world. Because of the gravity of this situation, and its potential to influence American policy for many years to come, I will use the utmost care in my response.

There is a temptation in such circumstances to respond in kind, quickly and fiercely. A people in as much pain as the American people naturally desire the satisfaction of striking back and exacting revenge. Yet we must think as well as feel if we are to truly avenge this despicable act. Though the deaths of three thousand innocent Americans cries out for vengeance, we must be sure that our response ultimately makes us stronger as a nation and ensures the continuation of our role as a leader in the cause of human liberty.

With that being said I would like to announce at this time the withdrawal of all foreign monetary aid to nations that do now or have in the past harbored or supported terrorists such as those ones behind yesterday’s attack and many other attacks against American citizens and service men and women over the past three decades. We are beginning to comprehend this killing of military personnel, as well as innocents, has been sanctioned, even ordered, by the leaders of these terrorist organizations. Men such as Osama Bin Laden, in fact, claim the murder of American citizens is a religious duty. As recently as May of this year Bin Laden said “Allah ordered us in this religion to purify Muslim land of all non-believers.” It is insulting to the American people that their tax dollars may help prop up the very people who want to kill them. Therefore, we will honor Mr. Bin Laden’s desire that the United States stop meddling in the Islamic world by stopping all non-trade related financial interference in that region.

As for a military response, let me say now that we will not be provoked into a response that will ultimately hurt the United States more than the enemy. I have too much respect for the men and women who wear the uniform of the United States to use them thoughtlessly and recklessly and so I promise you any future military action we might take will be carefully planned and then swiftly and effectively executed. The full wrath of the United States is an awesome and terrible thing and we will do all we can to make sure it is demonstrated against our true enemies.

At the same time, it has been said that war is the health of the state so we hope to resolve this situation decisively and then return to a secure and certain peace as quickly as possible. I would like to also assure the American people that the United States’ government will not use this event as an excuse to grow and take more power unto itself. Past wars have provided despotic leaders the opportunities to infringe upon and restrict civil liberties – I make a firm commitment to you now that this will not happen. Marcus Aurelius Antoninus said “The best way of avenging thyself is not to become like the wrong-doer” and I pledge that the document which has made America a great and open society, the Constitution, will not be sacrificed to this cause.

I thank you, my fellow Americans, for your examples of courage and compassion, for your prayers on my behalf and your willingness to stand together as a nation. May we always remember and display the unity and love of country we feel today. God bless you. And God bless America.

Thursday, September 9, 2010

Vermont Campaign for Liberty's Core Principles: Limited Constitutional Government


Surprisingly one of the hardest plank in the VTC4L's "platform" to get across to people is the idea of limited Constitutional Government. Whenever it is mentioned, the average Joe's eyes glaze over and a hint of fear washes over their faces. This reaction is understandable given that we live in an age of Santa Claus politicians, entitlements, and the ubiquity of the Statist attitude. However, in each exchange with our fellow Vermonters there is hope that minds are changing.


An old friend of the family stopped by the fair booth last night. Though he knew about my work with the Campaign, he was never really interested to learn more. After taking the World's Smallest Quiz, and scoring exactly like I thought he would (conservative statist), we started to talk about the conditions our nations finds itself.


In his seventies, my friend grew up in a world of ever-growing entitlement programs and expansive government. For most of his lifetime, he had been told that all of the troubles in the world could be solved by governmental action. However, since his birth during the Roosevelt administration until the era of "Hope and change", these problems seemed to have never gone away and still more problems were caused by the very entity that was to cure them. He honestly admitted a sense of hopelessness and impotence in the face of this growing wave of troubles. "If the government can't fix it, how can we?" He asked. I replied, "did it occur to you that many of the problems we face today has been the result of governmental attempts to fix everything?" He was taken aback by my observation, but the thought clearly struck a chord deep within him.


The Vermont Campaign for Liberty honors and cherishes the Constitutions of this State and the Nation. We believe that they were well-crafted and deliberate documents which were created with great care and forethought. Looking at contemporaneous documents (among them the Declaration of Independence and the Bill of Rights), we find that the spirit and the philosophy of a limited government is readily apparent.


The founders created a Federal Government with a complex system of checks and balances. The three branches curbing the impulses toward power in each other. The power of the Federal Government restrained by the sovereignty of the several states. The people being the ultimate check on all government, intervening when any of them becomes destructive to their liberty.


Looking specifically at the Federal Constitution, we know that the document envisioned a limit on its power through the enumeration of its authority in Article One, Section Eight. Under the traditional protocols of legal interpretation, whenever there is such an enumeration, it is assumed that such a list of powers serves as a limitation of authority. For if it were otherwise, then the enumeration would be rendered meaningless. Therefore, faced with this guide to interpretation, one would have to wonder why the Founders included such a list if it was not meant to act as a restraint upon the powers of the Federal Government.


Turning to the Bill of Rights, we have further evidence of this intent to limit the power of the Federal Government in the provisions found there, especially in Amendments IX and X. It has long been established that the Bill of Rights is not a statement of what rights you have. In fact, this document clearly set further limits on the Federal Government regarding what they can do while interacting with the average citizen. The Government can not restrict your rights to speak as you wish, pray or not as you wish, publish what you like, and gather together. The government can not prevent you from defending yourself. Your home is your castle, a domain which the government can't invade without just cause. The evils of a darker age in the law are abolished and the State must try you in open court, before a jury of your peers, and must find you guilty before punishing you. And when punishing you, the government can not use methods which are inhumane or bizarre. Finally, this document concludes with two reminders that the power of government is limited and the rights of the people are absolute. The Ninth Amendment clearly indicates that nothing mentioned before, either in the Constitution or the Bill of Rights, serve as a limit on the unnumerated rights that all people are born with. The Tenth Amendment further holds that those powers not specifically granted the Federal Government belong to the States and the people.


These fine-crafted documents created a government meant to perform specific things and to do so in a manner that is not destructive of the liberties of its people. Government was to be the referee in the game of society and commerce. It was to serve as the foundation and framework for our activities. It was to be the defender of our safety and liberty in the face of dangers both domestic and foreign. Government was to be the necessary evil that allowed civil society to function. However, time, ignorance, greed, covetousness, and apathy has lead us to this age of mega-government.


We, as a nation, have forgotten that the very wealth and opportunities we enjoy today came from the individual initiative of our fellow citizens, and not the government. We have been condition to consider every problem we face in the world around us as something government is best able to address. "There outta be a law!" has been the mantra of the people for way too long.


Long ago, it was observed that the government which governs least, governs best. With all of the failures, mishaps, waste, and fraud that plagues this nation due to the bloated bureaucracy of our governments, both state and national, this axiom has been proven true over and over again. Our government races to intrude more and more upon our daily lives, creating poorly thought out and financially unsustainable programs, all of which endanger our liberties, our labors, and our futures. The tidal wave of debt, regulations, and economic mismanagement must be stopped before it washes away all for which we have worked.


Our system, which no longer has the confidence of the average American, is out of balance. It no longer serves the long term interest of our nation and its people. The States, once sovereign and proud, are little more than financial junkies pitifully begging for another hit of stimulus dollars just to get by. Citizens of this great republic have become pliant servants of the grand scheme of the elites.


It is up to us to restore the balance. We must work to return our government to its constitutional foundations. It will not be done by protest or voting alone, but by the consistent effort of those who see the danger and can no longer standby and do nothing.


During the Constitutional Convention of 1787, the Founders assumed that the American people would be the ultimate restraint on the government they were creating. They feared the power and the passion of the average person. They knew that the American was jealous of his liberties and would take on anyone who sought to infringe upon them. It is time to fulfill that assumption and restore our Republic. It is time to return our government to its limited, constitutional role.

Thursday, September 2, 2010

P Stands for Pravda in VPR

Pravda  
By Deborah T. Bucknam

Recently I read a story about a young American who stayed with a family in Leningrad during the Soviet era. The family would gather around the TV set every night to watch the news. The young man reported that the news was unvarying: great news from the Soviet Union, good news from Eastern Europe, and bad news from the West. 


Vermont Public Radio follows the Soviet era model. A review of its morning and evening news broadcasts over the last several months reveals that VPR reports great news about Democrats and particularly our Democratic congressional delegation, good news from the Progressive party, and in the rare instances it reports on Republican candidates, bad news. 


Now that the campaign season is in full swing, VPR has ramped up its congressional happy talk. VPR broadcasts stories directly from Sen. Leahy, Sanders and Rep. Welch’s press offices, with quotes from our congressional leaders, including almost daily "news" about federal funds coming into Vermont, complete with a member of our Congressional delegation praising the worthiness of the funded programs. Other stories showcase Leahy, Sanders and Welch as fighters against greedy capitalists and gargantuan oil polluters. There were several "news" stories about Sen. Leahy in the "spotlight" as chair of the Senate Judiciary Committee, and two glowing articles about Leahy’s nearly 15 year unsuccessful "fight" for a landmine treaty. Another favorite VPR technique is to approvingly broadcast "news" about a member of our congressional delegation introducing bills in Congress. Never mind that introducing a bill is a non-event and the bill may never get past a subcommittee. 


None of these "stories" are newsworthy. They are merely congressional news releases dutifully re-broadcast by VPR. 


Stories about Republican campaigns are usually either negative or non-existent. For example, recently, after broadcasting stories about government stimulus funds coming to Vermont, thanks to Sanders and Welch, VPR broadcast a story that the largest campaign war chest in Vermont was funded by donors who were not aware that it was operated by a Republican Governor’s committee. The only comment VPR broadcast about the matter was from VPIRG, a far left advocacy organization (although VPR never names it as such) complaining that the fund should be "transparent". VPR also recently broadcast a Democrat’s criticism of Republican Auditor of Account’s campaign finance filing; negative remarks between Republican Secretary of State candidates, and two mistakes on Sarah Palin’s Facebook page when she endorsed a New Hampshire Republican candidate. Negative stories about Republicans are never too insignificant for the VPR news team. 


VPR has instituted a virtual news blackout of the U.S. Senate and House races here in Vermont. Thanks to VPR’s news embargo, for example, many Vermonters have not heard of the sole Republican Senate Candidate Len Britton, an attractive young Vermont businessman whose political views more closely mirror Vermonters’ opinions than do those of the antediluvian Sen. Leahy. Britton’s clever Youtube videos about our burgeoning national debt have caught national attention, including CBS news, but VPR has refused to broadcast any stories about this phenomenon. 


With Sen. Leahy’s campaign war chest at almost $3.5 million, the chances of Len Britton being heard above the Leahy din in the paid media are small. Similarly, Rep. Welch’s campaign war chest is also substantial, unlike his opponents. Because of Leahy’s and Welch’s rich store of campaign funds coupled with the their nearly daily free broadcasts from VPR, and VPR’s news blackout of Leahy’s and Welch’s opponents, Vermonters, like Soviet era citizens, have practically no opportunity to hear dissenting voices or to meaningfully participate in Vermont’s U.S. Congressional races.


VPR has become a well-behaved appendage of the Vermont Democratic political establishment instead of a vigorous First Amendment practitioner. Our Vermont democratic process suffers as a result. 

Deborah T. Bucknam, Esq.
Law Offices of Deborah T. Bucknam & Associates, PC